TL;DR
Yes, you can build a good Single Sign-On (SSO) system around a server signing tickets instead of validating them on demand. This approach – often called ‘signed tokens’ or ‘JWT-based SSO’ – is common and offers performance benefits. However, it requires careful key management and consideration for token revocation.
How It Works
- User Authentication: The user authenticates with an Identity Provider (IdP) – this could be your own login page or a third-party service like Google or Facebook.
- Ticket Creation & Signing: Upon successful authentication, the IdP creates a ticket containing information about the user (e.g., username, roles). This ticket is then digitally signed using the IdP’s private key. This signature proves the ticket’s authenticity and integrity.
- Ticket Delivery: The signed ticket is sent to the Service Provider (SP) – the application the user wants to access. Typically this is done via a redirect with the token in a query parameter or as an HTTP cookie.
- Ticket Verification: The SP receives the ticket and verifies its signature using the IdP’s public key. If the signature is valid, the SP trusts the information within the ticket.
- Access Granted: Based on the user information in the verified ticket, the SP grants access to the application.
Step-by-Step Implementation Guide
- Choose a Token Format: JSON Web Tokens (JWTs) are the most popular choice. They’re compact, self-contained and widely supported.
- Header: Specifies the signing algorithm (e.g., HS256, RS256).
- Payload: Contains user information (claims). Keep this data minimal for security reasons.
- Signature: Created using the IdP’s private key and the header/payload.
- Implement Token Signing on the IdP: Use a cryptography library in your chosen language to sign the JWT.
# Example Python with PyJWT import jwt payload = {'username': 'user123', 'roles': ['admin']} token = jwt.encode(payload, 'your_secret_key', algorithm='HS256') print(token) - Implement Token Verification on the SP: Use a similar cryptography library to verify the JWT’s signature.
# Example Python with PyJWT token = 'your_jwt_token' try: decoded_payload = jwt.decode(token, 'your_secret_key', algorithms=['HS256']) print(decoded_payload) except jwt.ExpiredSignatureError: # Token has expired print('Token Expired') except jwt.InvalidSignatureError: # Invalid signature print('Invalid Signature') - Key Management: Securely store and rotate the IdP’s private key.
- Use a Hardware Security Module (HSM) for maximum security.
- Regularly rotate keys to limit the impact of compromise.
- Never commit private keys to version control!
- Token Expiration: Set an appropriate expiration time for tokens.
- Short-lived tokens are more secure but require more frequent re-authentication.
- Balance security with user experience.
- Token Revocation (Important!): Signed tickets cannot be easily revoked once issued. Implement a mechanism to handle revocation.
- Blacklisting: Maintain a list of revoked tokens on the SP. This requires checking against the blacklist on every request, impacting performance.
- Short Token Lifetimes: Relying solely on short token lifetimes is a simple but less flexible approach.
- Refresh Tokens: Issue long-lived refresh tokens that can be used to obtain new access tokens. Revoking the refresh token effectively revokes access. This is the most common and recommended solution.
- Transport Security (HTTPS): Always use HTTPS to protect tickets in transit.
Advantages of Signed Tickets
- Performance: SPs don’t need to make real-time calls to the IdP for every request.
- Scalability: Reduced load on the IdP.
- Statelessness: SPs can be stateless, simplifying deployment and scaling.
Disadvantages
- Key Management Complexity: Requires robust key management practices.
- Token Revocation Challenges: Implementing effective token revocation is crucial but complex.
- Token Size: JWTs can be relatively large, impacting bandwidth.